Quote:
|
I think this is where "Bash This Mix" and "Bash This Song" come in... if I remember correctly, either these used to be separate and got combined, or Brandon was just talking about splitting them up... it might be time to do it.
|
They were once split and it became impossible to isolate them. Guys would post a song in Bash This Mix but then the arrangement or performance would be flawed. I decided that it was impossible to separate the music from the engineering and I merged the two together. I have no plans of splitting them. This is the best way in my opinion.
Quote:
|
For me, the benefit of this forum is to improve my "best efforts", not my "unpolished thoughts".. so in turn, I really want to critique your best work, not your unfinished work.
|
I 100% agree. From an engineering standpoint, a person should bust their butt to get a mix to be as good as it can possibly be. Then ask for help. If you know X, Y, and Z are screwed up it doesn't make sense to post it in my opinion.
When I mix, I'm a one-track mind kind of a guy. If something is screwed, I focus on it and nothing else. So when I hear that X, Y, and Z are flawed I have a hard time looking past those flaws.
Quote:
|
Maybe make an extra forum in the Bash section for "unfinished ideas"?
|
This is the way to go.
Unfinished Ideas - Home Recording Forum
This will let us keep the "quality" factor high in the standard sections, but give us a "bullpin" where guys can work out their ideas.
Brandon