If I were going to the bar and you happened to be up on stage doing this, I'd be cool with it and probably sing along in my seat.
If it were on a tribute compilation, I'd expect just a bit more from it, but I wouldn't be unhappy.
Sounds like if you spent a bit more time on it, you could pull off a real passable cover of it.
My brother does this tune a lot for fun and it's one of my favorite AIC tunes. Good choice.
